Erika Kirk has claimed she “never dated” while residing in New York City during the late 2010s, a period spanning from approximately 2012 to 2021. However, documented evidence contradicts this assertion.
Records indicate that by 2018, Kirk lived in Manhattan or Brooklyn and began dating Charlie Kirk in New York City in September 2018. She obtained her New York real estate license in October 2018 and worked as an agent for the Corcoran Group in the city.
The discrepancy became apparent when Kirk stated she had not dated during her time in New York, despite being featured on a dating reality television show. Archival evidence from the Wayback Machine reveals that Kirk posted about her relationship with Cabot Phillips on September 19, 2017. Just seven days later, on September 24, 2017, Charlie Kirk shared social media posts indicating he had defeated Phillips in a one-on-one basketball game.
Additionally, Phillips has since replaced Charlie Kirk on the TPUSA speaking circuit, delivering a talk titled “How To Lead Like Charlie.” Kirk claims she met Charlie Kirk during an Israel tour and that he offered her a job interview leading to a date. However, the timeline suggests she was dating Phillips prior to meeting Charlie Kirk.