Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier has filed a $5 million civil lawsuit against the City of Jacksonville, alleging the municipality knowingly maintained an illegal gun registry in violation of state law.
Uthmeier stated his office “lacks jurisdiction to prosecute” but asserts a duty under Florida Statutes to enforce consistent application of state law. The suit targets the city’s logbooks, which documented over 100 individuals—including their names, birthdates, ID numbers, and firearm types—from July 2023 through April 2025. Uthmeier contends these entries constitute a prohibited “list, record, or registry” under Section 790.335(2)(a) of Florida Statutes, which forbids local governments or government employees from knowingly maintaining records of privately owned firearms.
In a letter responding to State Attorney Melissa Nelson’s January 2026 decision not to pursue criminal charges, Uthmeier rejected the state attorney’s finding that no one acted “knowingly and willfully.” He argued the statute requires only intent to maintain a log and knowledge that it documented private firearms, noting ignorance of the law is not a defense.
Uthmeier further alleged that city attorneys as early as 2007 warned Jacksonville could not create or maintain such a registry. The complaint claims the logbook policy was approved by former Deputy Chief Administrative Officer Charles Moreland on July 13, 2024—less than two weeks after Mayor Donna Deegan assumed office—and compiled with “the knowledge or complicity of City management.” This contradicts an eight-month investigation by the State Attorney’s Office, which found no criminal wrongdoing and stated the city employee involved had not realized their actions violated the law.
Uthmeier previously characterized the city’s registry as “unlawful and reprehensible,” emphasizing that Florida law permits civil penalties of up to $5 million against municipalities complicit in maintaining illegal gun records.