When the framers of the First Amendment established the right to peaceful protest, they did not carve out an exemption for those who advocate against the termination of human life in the womb.

In New Jersey, Democratic lawmakers are now attempting to pass legislation that would criminalize pro-life activists if their demonstrations cause emotional harm to individuals involved in reproductive healthcare services.

Bills A2218 and S2260 aim to prohibit protesters from “intimidating” people outside abortion clinics and health insurers from denying coverage for abortion services. Under the proposed law, a person commits interference with reproductive healthcare services if they “purposely or knowingly” cause a reasonable person to suffer damage including financial harm, loss of reputation, pain and suffering, mental anguish, or emotional harm based on their involvement in reproductive healthcare.

The bill imposes civil penalties up to $10,000 for the first violation and $25,000 for subsequent violations.

The legislation has drawn criticism from constitutional experts and the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU). According to a statement from the ACLU of New Jersey Legislative Director John Butler: “We have been supportive overall, but this one provision is concerning. From our point of view, we want protections for abortion providers and clients but we also need to protect people’s constitutional rights to speech.”

The proposed laws have also faced backlash from advocates who argue that they would punish truthful reporting about reproductive healthcare services. The ACLU notes that a reporter could face civil or criminal liability for publishing well-documented and accurate information about a provider’s practices, even if the reporting is factual.

In a separate case highlighting risks of federal enforcement against pro-life activists, Mark Houck, a Catholic father of seven and pro-life activist, was arrested by federal agents in 2022 after an altercation at a Planned Parenthood facility. The incident led to a lawsuit that resulted in a settlement of more than $1 million with the U.S. Department of Justice.

Houck and his wife, Ryan-Marie, alleged that they and their children suffered severe psychological trauma following the raid, including post-traumatic stress, economic loss, and loss of reputation. They also reported that their children experienced intense anxiety, constant fear of losing their parents, and sleep disturbances. Additionally, Ryan-Marie suffered three miscarriages and was diagnosed with infertility as a result of the legal ordeal.