D.C. schools are facing federal scrutiny over the trustworthiness of student attendance records and graduation decisions. A special grand jury convened by U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro is investigating the District’s oversight of young people, with school personnel being questioned about absences and graduation practices.

The investigation does not establish criminal misconduct but places the paperwork behind diplomas under fresh scrutiny. Preliminary data for the 2025-26 academic year indicates that 50.4% of D.C. high school students are classified as chronically truant, encompassing both traditional public and charter schools.

At Ballou High School, the rate was reported at 84.4%, while Anacostia High School had a rate of 84.1%. These figures represent students who have crossed an absence threshold, not the proportion of school days missed.

Federal prosecutors contacted educators and other school employees regarding truancy, graduation rates, and attendance records, with some connections to Ballou High School. This raises critical questions for those managing the system: when students repeatedly miss class, who follows up on their absences, and what procedures are followed before a student receives a high school diploma?

The District has previously investigated improper graduation practices, yielding serious findings. In November 2018, the Office of the State Superintendent of Education (OSSE) summarized four key issues from an earlier Alvarez & Marsal investigation: credit recovery was misused at most DCPS high schools, attendance-related grading rules were rarely followed, central-office oversight was inadequate, and many schools developed a culture of passing students who failed to meet requirements.

The follow-up review requested supporting documents for 218 graduates certified in 2018—a sample representing 10% of that cohort. The sample disproportionately included students with significant unexcused absences from comprehensive high schools.

This history explains why attendance records and graduation certifications require concurrent examination. A graduation rate measures one outcome but cannot independently confirm whether the rules governing each diploma were properly followed.

Those findings pertain to past academic years and do not indicate that current misconduct has occurred in 2025-26 or that any present employees are guilty of wrongdoing.

There is also a measurement issue: OSSE’s 2024-25 attendance page defines chronic truancy as at least 10 full-day, unexcused absences during the school year. Chronic absenteeism is defined separately as missing at least 10% of enrolled days, regardless of excusal status.

Ten missed days and 10% of an enrolled school year represent different thresholds, particularly for students enrolled for only part of the year. OSSE also requires three certifications by local education agencies before finalizing attendance data.

In contrast, preliminary figures for 2025-26 use a 10% unexcused-absence threshold—according to information attributed to OSSE—which needs clarification before drawing definitive conclusions about year-to-year comparisons.

High absence rates alone cannot be used to assume that graduates were ineligible for their diplomas. Student-level records, course requirements, and evidence of decision-making processes are necessary for such assessments.

Mayor Muriel Bowser’s office stated its immediate focus is the new school year, with school data remaining public.

Publishing these figures is essential. Families deserve to know what schools do when a child stops attending, what support reaches that student, and whether graduation requirements are consistently enforced.

The federal inquiry has yet to answer these questions. The records themselves should provide clarity.