The Justice Department has released records revealing that work continued after the FBI withdrew its contentious Richmond Catholic memo in February 2023. The newly disclosed documents show an analyst revising the document more than a month following public backlash, internal disputes over its premise, and investigations of two priests who faced scrutiny but were found innocent.

The memo, initially published inside the Justice Department on January 23, 2023, attempted to link certain traditionalist Catholics with racially or ethnically motivated violent extremism. After withdrawal, an FBI analyst wrote in a March 17 email that revisions—including changes to terminology and analysis—were underway, though formal adoption required leadership approval.

The records highlight internal objections from the bureau’s counterterrorism specialists, who questioned the memo’s validity. They cited unsupported conclusions, reliance on unverified sources like Southern Poverty Law Center claims, and inadequate credibility assessments. Catholic leaders who attend traditional Latin Mass also criticized the document’s treatment of religious beliefs.

The case began with an individual accused of violent conduct involving weapons and Molotov cocktails, resulting in an eight-year prison sentence. However, investigators found no wrongdoing by two priests linked to him—neither had attended regular church services, maintained parish ties, or participated in sacraments. One priest explicitly rejected the man’s racist views and sought legal counsel before engaging further with authorities.

The Justice Department report confirms neither priest was found guilty of any misconduct. It also details internal responses: disciplinary actions including admonishments and additional training, alongside favorable annual evaluations from Richmond leadership that acknowledged the memo’s flaws and resulting corrections. Crucially, the records indicate no evidence of malicious intent or improper purpose in developing the memo, though the FBI’s own Inspection Division identified poor judgment and failures to meet standards.

With these documents now public, the withdrawal represents only one phase of a broader review. The underlying facts—how an investigation into individual violence expanded to scrutinize religious practice without finding wrongdoing—remain available for Congress and the public to examine.