A historical court document from February 23, 1991 reveals that Sunny Hostin (Asuncion Cummings) has misrepresented her role as a juror in the infamous Daniel Rakowitz murder trial.
In the case involving Monika Beerle, a 29-year-old woman killed by Rakowitz in August 1989, he was found not guilty by reason of insanity after nine days of deliberation. The court record states that one juror held out for an insanity verdict, but another juror—identified as Asuncion Cummings—stated: “Yes, we believe he did it. I believe he butchered the body and almost committed the perfect crime.”
According to the document, the holdout juror was not Hostin but an unemployed man who allegedly wanted to extend his $15-a-day juror fee. The record further notes that Asuncion Cummings expressed strong belief in Rakowitz’s guilt.
Hostin has publicly claimed on The View that she was the holdout juror who convinced the jury to acquit Rakowitz by reason of insanity. However, the historical record contradicts this account.