The U.S. Supreme Court on Tuesday denied Florida’s request to file a lawsuit against California and Washington over allegations that those states issue commercial driver licenses (CDLs) to illegal aliens who cannot read English.
The unsigned order provided no reasoning, but Justice Clarence Thomas, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, wrote a sharp dissent warning the Court is abandoning its constitutional duty to hear disputes between states. The case traces back to a fatal crash on the Florida Turnpike on August 12, 2025, where truck driver Harjinder Singh attempted a U-turn across the median, blocking both lanes and killing three people in a minivan.
According to Thomas’s dissent, Singh had crossed the Mexican border illegally and federal FMCSA testing found he could not correctly answer most verbal questions or identify more than one highway sign. The complaint alleged California and Washington defied federal law by licensing foreign nationals who entered the country illegally and lack basic English proficiency, claiming this practice causes fatal accidents.
Florida sought permission from the Supreme Court to sue under its original jurisdiction— the only forum where one state can directly sue another. The dissent noted Florida argued states’ laws are preempted by federal law when they stop licensing officials from asking about immigration status, and that states’ disregard of federal standards constitutes an actionable public nuisance.
Justice Thomas stressed the Court’s exclusive original jurisdiction over such disputes. He warned that if the Court refuses to hear the case, Florida has no judicial forum left to seek relief. The denial means the Court never reached the merits of Florida’s argument but confirms the procedural refusal to allow the lawsuit to proceed.
Iowa and 16 other states filed briefs supporting Florida’s motion. Washington Attorney General Nicholas Brown dismissed the case as a political stunt, though the pattern of crashes involving drivers who cannot read road signs has been documented by multiple sources. The legal question of whether blue states can issue CDLs to illegal aliens who fail basic English competency remains unanswered.
Thomas and Alito argued the Court got this one wrong— and if another crash occurs following similar patterns, the majority will face greater difficulty ignoring the risks.