Federal District Judge Brian Murphy has lifted the last judicial obstacle to President Trump’s decision to terminate Temporary Protected Status for more than 5,000 Ethiopians residing in the United States.
This ruling permits the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to immediately proceed with ending the TPS designation while a narrower constitutional challenge continues through the courts. The practical effect is immediate: protections allowing thousands of Ethiopian nationals to remain and work legally in the U.S. no longer face judicial delay.
Judge Murphy rejected the remaining nonconstitutional arguments used to block the termination, including claims that the 1990 TPS law granted termination authority exclusively to the Attorney General rather than DHS. His decision aligns with recent rulings involving South Sudan, Myanmar, and Somalia under similar challenges.
The administration previously faced a temporary injunction from Judge Murphy in April, who ruled that DHS likely failed to follow required procedures. This was reversed following a June Supreme Court ruling in Mullin v. Doe, which held courts cannot review nonconstitutional challenges to TPS terminations. The Supreme Court also found plaintiffs lacked sufficient likelihood of success on racial or national-origin bias allegations to warrant interim relief.
After the Supreme Court decision, the First Circuit Court of Appeals reversed Murphy’s April order on July 29, directing immediate termination of Ethiopian TPS. DHS General Counsel James Percival described the outcome as a legal victory for the administration’s immigration agenda.
The termination follows the Biden administration’s initial grant of TPS protection in 2022 due to armed conflict and humanitarian conditions in Ethiopia, extended and redesignated in 2024. DHS concluded Ethiopia no longer met statutory requirements after reviewing current conditions with federal agencies. Under federal law, TPS is a temporary measure for nationals from countries facing extraordinary conditions—allowing legal presence, work authorization, and deportation protection without conferring citizenship or residency rights.
The administration has maintained TPS is intended as short-term humanitarian relief, not a substitute for regular immigration pathways. Opponents argue dangerous conditions persist in Ethiopia, risking the safety of individuals who have built lives in the United States. For now, the legal battle over termination proceeds without an active judicial block.